Novelty

  • Gabby Gibbler plush with pink ruffled bonnet and light yellow shaggy fur
    New in
    Fugglers

    Old Fogies Gabby Gibbler Plush

    $35
    $35
    OR $26.25 for Members
  • Green fuzzy baby monster plush with blue eyes, purple mouth, gray bow tie
    New in
    Fugglers

    Baby Fugg Series 3 Shameless Goof

    $15
    $15
    OR $11.25 for Members
  • Gold plush World Cup trophy, map pattern, green FIFA band, hanging product tag
    New in
    Jazwares

    FIFA World Cup 2026 10-inch Plush Trophy

    $20
    $20
    OR $15 for Members
  • Black plush soccer ball with FIFA World Cup print and gray panel pattern
    New in
    Jazwares

    2026 World Cup 9" Black Plush Soccer Ball - Black

    $35
    $35
    OR $26.25 for Members
  • Retro game-themed plush surprise ball in purple with accessories and cards
    New in
    Miraball

    Miraball Surprises Retro, Assorted Characters - Surprise Unboxing Fun, 3 in 1

    $15
    $15
    OR $11.25 for Members
  • Yellow emoji smile plush ball with handle loop, surprise capsule and sticker figures
    New in
    Miraball

    MiraBall Surprises Emoji Toy Blind Capsule with Expandable Memory Foam Plush and Stickers

    $15
    $15
    OR $11.25 for Members
  • Mini surprise machine with pink top, front box, and cute cat cotton-themed graphics
    New in
    Cotton Cuties

    Mini Machine Sorpresa

    $25
    $25
    OR $18.75 for Members
  • Alien plush in purple, long-pile monster face with three eyes and teeth
    New in
    Fugglers

    Fart Face Series 1 (Alien - long pile)

    $39
    $39
    OR $29.25 for Members
  • Hairy Fuggs plush in window box, purple monster with pink fuzzy hood and teeth
    New in
    Fugglers

    Hairy Fuggs Plush in window box

    $29
    $29
    OR $21.75 for Members
  • Vacay Vibes Smiley O Riley plush, green knit monster with big eyes, pink mouth & straps
    New in
    Fugglers

    Vacay Vibes Smiley O Riley

    $30
    $30
    OR $22.50 for Members
  • Gunky Goober Plushfigur mit orangefarbenem Fell und großen rosa Augenbrillen
    New in
    Fugglers

    Fuggstars! Gunky Goober Plush

    $45
    $45
    OR $33.75 for Members
  • Laboratory Misfits Monster Plush, peluche rojo con boca morada y dientes blancos
    New in
    Fugglers

    Laboratory Misfits Monster Plush

    $30
    $30
    OR $22.50 for Members